The Whistleblower Film Review
Heading into the last month of Spring and the first of Summer is always a juncture where I begin an accounting, of sorts. An attempt in taking stock of where everything is at, as it were. My children are ending their school year (with one reaching their elementary school culmination before starting middle school come September) and beginning a break. Time marches on with its usual, inexorable manner, and attempting to hold back the tide is a study in futility for even attempting the endeavor. But, I do it anyway.
With that bit reasoning, here we are at the end of the month again. Time for the blogger otherwise known as the Scientist Gone Wordy and I to execute another of our reviews in parallel. As is our modus operandi, the wordy one will look at a book well-known enough to later be adapted to the screen, which I will review. In this case, she’ll be looking at our first non-fiction book in the series, one that detailed some truly ugly real-life events. The Whistleblower: Sex Trafficking, Military Contractors, and One Woman’s Fight for Justice was published in January 2011. I’ll look at its film adaptation, which was released last summer with little fanfare. Rachel’s book review can be found here:
The Whistleblower by Kathryn Bolkovac
A brief synopsis of the film: a divorced police officer, Kathryn Bolkovac, decides to take a job with a U.N. peace keeping action helping to settle and train law enforcement in post-war Bosnia. She’ll work for the U.K. company called Democra Security providing the services. Initially, the high pay six-month contract is the draw. Still, her skills as an experienced investigator leads to a promotion as head of the department for gender affairs. Yet, when she looks at wrongdoing involving young women at a local area club her investigation exposes sex trafficking. Her work and life suffers in the resulting upheaval. Primarily initiated with the discovery of young Ukrainian woman named Raya, who had recently been sold by her uncle into a forced prostitution ring, Kathryn finds a widespread corruption encompassing club ownership, the traffickers, and even those in your own peace-keeping force. The gist of the story is what happens when she attempts to bring the truth of what’s going on into the light.
[spoiler warning: some key elements of the film could be revealed in this review]
“It’s not me. It’s policy.”
A couple of months back, Rachel first suggested this book/film combo as a possible title for our duo post series. I’d heard of it, but not much in the way of the details with the events covered. In the time since, by mere chance, I read/listened to two other works of non-fiction that turned out to be very much related. The first was Drift: The Unmooring of American Military Power by Rachel Maddow, and just recently The Year That Changed The World: The Untold Story of the Fall of the Berlin Wall by Michael Meyer. The first covered, in part, our country’s increased dependency of military contractors (specifically through the latter decades of the 20th century and tied to hefty Pentagon defense contracts) in places like Bosnia, Afghanistan, Iraq, etc. The second (the one I finished last weekend) detailed the seminal change in 1989 that brought about the byproduct depicted here, through the unshackling of Soviet control in eastern Europe that helped to unleash the historic ethnic hatreds. The result ended up as the charnel house that was Yugoslavia’s breakup.
“During your training you will see that peace is harder won than war. That every morning’s hope is haunted by yesterday’s nightmare.”
The Larysa Kondracki film is a gripping and unexpected work by a first time director. It is a bit of an ordeal, too. That’s not so much meant as a criticism rather that the subject it seeks to examine is one that’ll make most civilized human beings cringe. I mean, indentured servitude of the worst kind (forced prostitution and sexual physical abuse for the worst entertainment value imaginable) will have that effect on viewers. It did me. Kondracki’s treatment of Kathryn Bolkovac’s real life exposé, with the deft assistance of writer Cari Lynn, detailing the former Nebraska police officer and divorced mother of three unearthing this kind of human trafficking exploitation in the midst of a U.N. mercy mission, was properly sobering, no matter how you cut it.
It is a pity that this story, told as a fictional drama and a thriller, didn’t get much in exposure or play (besides some film festivals and human rights awards) beyond the limited release in the U.S. and Canada during the last year’s Summer movie season (Europe and Asia theatrical runs came later during the Fall). Carrying the label of “Inspired by true events.” is its own throttle, too. No wonder it got lost amid the typical fare during that time. As well, screenwriters Kondracki (doing double-duty) and Eilis Kirwan had to thread the needle in adapting the non-fiction book to the screen and thereby protect the
guilty innocent. Or, at least prevent the film’s backers from litigation. The U.S. based DynCorp International morphed into the U.K. company called Democra Security in this cinematic telling.
The film also benefited in having key characters portrayed by the likes of Rachel Weisz, as Kathryn Bolkovac, Vanessa Redgrave and David Strathairn. These performers never fail at giving their roles (large or small) good turns that made them at the very least memorable. I was kind of surprised to see the new BBC modern-day Sherlock Holmes, Benedict Cumberbatch, as well as Monica Bellucci showing up in brief but suspicious looking parts in this motion picture. Beyond that, what was also riveting in this production likely came as an offshoot of the limited budget that was pretty apparent in the movie. The Whistleblower had a distinct raw feel to it. Two scenes in particular, Rachel’s plea to Raya late in the film and the traffickers retaliation against the girls, were undeniably powerful enough the viewer could physically feel and retch along with those onscreen. Ultimately, it did add a quality that helped tell a true and rending story (at least under the veil of modern cinema intrigue).
“Ooh. Honey, it’s like I say, this is Bosnia. These people specialize in “fucked up”.”
There’s no getting around that this was a solid effort at translating a difficult, depressing account on to film. That it is dispiriting, even with a clever betrayal bit offered up at the end, which had a satisfying though hollow tinge to it, worked well enough at bringing an important message out. Even if this subject exerts itself against the notion that going to the movies is a relaxing diversion, it was hard to look at or look away from what ended up on the screen. The same budget limitations that brought a real rawness to the production, by sticking to real events, may have kept a number of performers marginalized here, however. As a viewer, I wanted more development of character beyond that of the central whistleblower. I mean, Liam Cunningham, a really charismatic actor, like Redgrave and Strathairn, wasn’t given much to do past the figurehead villain role. Barely enough to make you really pull for the good guys or hate the miscreants, IMO. Okay, I admit the same guy who portrayed the assh*le Gorman in Aliens as the HR guy in this, along with Vlad Ivanov as Tanjo, I wanted to strangle personally as I screened this.
The Whistleblower remains a very good, though not perfect, film. Certainly one that will piss off (in a righteous way) most that see it. Its fictionalized account of the scandal involving a major military contractor and others, something I suspect is still being tamped down to this day, made for a very competent and compelling thriller. Unquestionably, one with enough dread and atmosphere (the cold gray skies and landscape of Romania and Canada stood in too well for Bosnia) that never bored this viewer in its 112 minute runtime. It’s no surprise to most of us that those who expose the things groups, governments, corporations and PR firms want to remain hidden get shafted. And on a regular, continuing basis. That it also fills one with rage shouldn’t be a shocker, either. Moviegoers aren’t going to twiddle their thumbs while watching this, that’s for sure. They may squirm in their chairs, or get off the sofa from time-to-time with the excuse they need a bathroom break or something to drink in the vain hopes of getting away from the nagging thoughts Bolkovac’s tale offered, though.
Parallel Post Series
- Drive (book/audiobook review)
- The Big Sleep
- The Maltese Falcon
- Rosemary’s Baby
- The Hunt for Red October
- The Day of The Jackal
- Somewhere in Time (aka Bid Time Return)
- Starship Troopers
- Jurassic Park
- Free Fall
- Get Carter (aka Jack’s Return Home)
- Devil in a Blue Dress
- Angel Heart (aka Falling Angel)
- The Lathe of Heaven
- The Princess Bride
- A Scanner Darkly
- Children of Men
- Minority Report
17 Responses to “The Whistleblower Film Review”
Thank you for the review Mike 🙂
I have been wondering about this movie ever since I fell in love with Benedict. I want to see ALL his movies but I also want to know what is it about before seeing it.
Glad I could help, Novroz. Thank you for reading.
Hey Michael, it’s sounds like you felt very much the same as I did while watching. All the emotions and responses you mentioned were also what I felt when watching. It’s a very sobering topic and will make anyone squirm with sadness and rage.
Great observation on how the budget affected the tone and that it was for the better. It’s nice when a film maker can use limitations to enhance a movie as a story telling device. One big difference I saw in the movie from the book is that the movie really focuses on and illustrates the horror that the victims were going through while the book focuses on and makes very clear how systematic was the abuse and cover-up. I think they compliment each other quite well as companion pieces as both perspectives are important. (Thought I would mention that DynCorp had a US based division and a UK based division – another whistleblower sued under the US division during the events of the book and he eventually settled. Bolkovac was hired under the UK division of the company. The company is now based in Dubai rather than the US or the UK.)
I’m glad you mentioned the other book about military contractors. It’s certainly an important subject to be informed about. It seems to be a trend in many US military strategies.
I know it’s not our usual fare but I’m glad we did this one. Great review, as always!
Yeah, it was a good and important film that wasn’t the easiest to watch (or say you really enjoyed). And yes, sadness and rage were the apt emotions in the viewing experience. Rachel Weisz was showcased well and was certainly up for the performance as the whistleblower Kathryn Bolkovac.
Why am I not surprised DynCorp has moved operations to Dubai. The drift toward military contractors remains a troubling one (see Maddow’s book for the other bad effects), plus its cost savings (the original selling point) are more than dubious.
Great recommendation for the book/film, Rachel. Many thanks.
Great review Michael. I will give the movie a watch as I think Rachel Weisz is an underrated actress who hasn’t had a chance to prove her abilities very often. Seems like it provoked a lot of emotions from you so I look forward to checking it out.
Rachel Weisz is very much one of the best attributes of the film. That one scene that I mentioned in the review is wrenching due to her performance in it. I’d be interested to hear or read your thoughts when you screen it. Thanks very much for the kind words, Castor.
Great review! I’ve been meaning to check this out, and now your review just makes me want to see it even more. I agree w/ Castor that Weisz is an underrated actress indeed!
Great to see another fan of Rachel Weisz, Ruth. She’s a grand one, alright. Thank you very much for reading and the kind words :-).
This is a great review, as so many others mentioned. I didn’t and still don’t have a big inclination to see this one, but I’m glad to see that the movie brought out of you the feelings that I guess it intended. That’s a good sign.
and Weisz is a fantastic actress
Yay to find another Weisz fan. Thanks so much for reading and your comment, T.
[…] The Whistleblower Film Review (le0pard13.com) Share and Enjoy: This entry was posted in Community, Community Events, National, News, Non Profit World, Public Education and tagged ABC, America Conference, Canada, Giselle Rodriguez, Kathryn Bolkovac, Laura Lederer, Lauren Murphy, Marion Williams, Melissa Woodward, New York Times, Norma Ramos, sex trafficking, United States, Washington DC, WKRN Channel 2, Yvonne Williams. Bookmark the permalink. ← Final Preparations for 2012 Trafficking In America Conference […]
[…] The Whistleblower […]
[…] The Whistleblower […]
[…] The Whistleblower […]
[…] The Whistleblower […]
[…] The Whistleblower […]
[…] Remind me to listen to this woman more often. Much like her suggestion last year for 2010′s The Whistleblower, which, as here, also starred the talented Rachel Weisz, it enthralled. Made me think, too, and […]